Introduction
The growth of technology and the increasing use of the internet have made communication, business and everyday activities much easier. However, these developments have also led to an increase in cybercrime, such as online fraud, identity theft, hacking, cyberstalking and other criminal activities carried out through digital platforms. These offences affect individuals, businesses and government institutions, often resulting in financial losses and the exposure of private information. From a legal point of view, prosecuting cybercrime can be challenging because much of the evidence needed to prove these offences exist in electronic form. Such evidence, which includes text messages, emails, social media conversations, call records and financial transaction details, is important in identifying suspects, investigating offences and establishing criminal responsibility before a court of law.
One important issue in handling digital evidence is maintaining a proper chain of custody. This refers to the process of recording how evidence is collected, handled, transferred and stored from the time it is obtained until it is presented in court. Proper chain of custody helps to ensure that evidence remains genuine, reliable and has not been altered or tampered with. However, maintaining this process is not always easy, as digital evidence can be deleted, manipulated or lost, while some investigators may lack the necessary technical skills and equipment to handle it properly. These difficulties can create problems during prosecution, particularly when the authenticity or reliability of the evidence is questioned in court. This article therefore examines the importance of digital evidence and chain of custody in prosecuting cybercrime, the challenges involved and the legal measures that can be adopted to improve the handling of digital evidence in Nigeria.
Meaning and Nature of Digital Evidence.
Digital evidence refers to any information or records stored or shared electronically that can be used to prove or disprove a fact in a legal case. It is an important part of criminal investigations, especially in cases involving cybercrime, because many of these offences leave behind electronic records. Examples include emails, text messages, social media chats, computer files, CCTV footage, call records, online banking transactions and internet browsing records. These forms of evidence can help investigators understand how an offence was committed, when it happened and who may have been involved. However, unlike physical evidence, digital evidence can easily be deleted, changed or transferred, which makes it necessary to handle and preserve it carefully.
From a legal point of view, digital evidence helps investigators identify suspects and establish their involvement in criminal activities. For example, bank transaction records may help expose online fraud, while text messages and social media conversations may provide information linking a suspect to an offence. However, not every electronic record can automatically be accepted by a court. Its authenticity, reliability and source must be properly established before it can be relied upon during proceedings. In Nigeria, Section 84 of the Evidence Act 2011, as amended, provides for the admissibility of computer-generated evidence. Therefore, digital evidence must be properly collected, preserved and presented in accordance with the law to ensure that it can be relied upon in the prosecution of cybercrime.
Chain of Custody in Digital Evidence
Chain of custody refers to the proper recording and handling of evidence from the time it is collected until it is presented in court. In cybercrime cases, it involves collecting, documenting, preserving and storing digital evidence without altering its original condition. Investigators must keep records of who handled the evidence and when it was transferred to ensure that it remains safe and reliable.
Maintaining a proper chain of custody helps prove that digital evidence is genuine and has not been tampered with. Where evidence is poorly handled or improperly documented, its reliability may be questioned in court, which can weaken the prosecution’s case. In Nigeria, Section 84 of the Evidence Act 2011, as amended, provides for the admissibility of computer-generated evidence.
Legal Framework Governing Digital Evidence in Nigeria
In Nigeria, the use of digital evidence in court is guided by several laws, particularly the Evidence Act 2011, as amended. Section 84 explains the conditions that must be met before computer-generated evidence can be accepted in court. The Cybercrimes (Prohibition, Prevention, etc.) Act 2015, as amended in 2024, also provides for the investigation and prosecution of cybercrime in the country. In addition, Section 37 of the 1999 Constitution protects the privacy of individuals, which must be respected when collecting personal information and electronic records during investigations.
Law enforcement agencies, including the Nigeria Police Force and other relevant security agencies, are responsible for investigating cybercrime and collecting necessary evidence. Digital forensic experts also assist by examining electronic devices, recovering information and preparing reports that may be used in court. It is important that these officers and experts handle evidence properly to avoid alteration or loss. Their work helps establish the reliability of digital evidence and ensures that it can be presented and relied upon during criminal proceedings.
Challenges in Prosecuting Cybercrime
One of the major difficulties in prosecuting cybercrime is proving that digital evidence is genuine and has not been altered or tampered with. Unlike physical evidence, electronic information can easily be deleted, changed or manipulated, making it difficult to establish its reliability in court. There is also the problem of preserving such evidence, as important information may be lost before investigators can properly secure it. In some cases, poor documentation and improper handling of evidence can affect the chain of custody and give the defense reasons to challenge its reliability during trial.
Another challenge is the lack of adequate forensic equipment, technical facilities and trained personnel to handle cybercrime investigations. Some law enforcement agencies lack the necessary skills and resources to recover deleted information, examine electronic devices and trace online criminal activities. Jurisdiction is also a problem because cybercrime can involve suspects, victims and computer systems located in different countries. This often makes investigations difficult, as Nigerian authorities may need the cooperation of foreign law enforcement agencies to obtain relevant information and identify offenders.
Privacy is another important concern when collecting digital evidence. Although investigators need access to electronic records to prove criminal offences, they must also respect the constitutional right to privacy under Section 37 of the 1999 Constitution. Accessing private messages, emails and personal information without proper legal authority may violate individuals’ rights and create further legal problems. Therefore, investigators must ensure that digital evidence is obtained lawfully while protecting the privacy of individuals and following the proper procedures required by law.
Recommendations
The Nigerian government should take steps to strengthen the existing laws and institutions responsible for handling digital evidence in criminal investigations. There is also a need to provide proper training for police officers, prosecutors, judges and forensic experts so they can understand how to collect, examine and present electronic evidence in court. In addition, more digital forensic laboratories, modern equipment and technical facilities should be provided to support investigations and ensure that important evidence is not lost or improperly handled. Clear guidelines should also be established to regulate how digital evidence is collected, preserved, stored and presented during criminal proceedings.
Furthermore, Nigeria should strengthen its cooperation with other countries in investigating and prosecuting cybercrime, especially where suspects or electronic evidence are located outside the country. Law enforcement agencies should be able to work with their foreign counterparts to obtain relevant information and trace offenders. However, these investigations must be carried out within the limits of the law, with proper respect for individuals’ constitutional rights, particularly the right to privacy under Section 37 of the 1999 Constitution. Adopting these measures will improve the handling of digital evidence, make cybercrime prosecution more effective and strengthen public confidence in the Nigerian justice system.
Conclusion
Digital evidence has become an important part of investigating and prosecuting cybercrime in Nigeria. It helps establish the facts of a case, identify suspects and provide evidence of criminal activities. However, such evidence must be properly collected, preserved and presented before it can be relied upon in court. A properly maintained chain of custody is therefore essential to show that the evidence is genuine, reliable and has not been tampered with.
There is also a need for stronger laws, improved forensic facilities, adequate training and proper procedures for handling digital evidence. Law enforcement agencies and other relevant authorities must ensure that investigations are carried out in accordance with the law while respecting individuals’ fundamental rights, particularly the right to privacy. Ultimately, effective prosecution of cybercrime requires a balance between the use of modern technology, compliance with legal procedures and the protection of individual rights. This will help strengthen the Nigerian justice system and ensure that those responsible for cybercrime are brought to justice.
This article is for information purposes only. Please seek expert guidance for your specific matters.
For expert guidance on arbitration, litigation, and dispute resolution matters, please contact our specialized team in the Corporate & Commercial Law Practice , Part of our full-service offering across Lagos, Abuja, and Abakaliki. Please contact our partner Hans Offia on [email protected]
REFERENCE
Federal Republic of Nigeria. (2015). Cybercrimes (Prohibition, Prevention, etc.) Act, 2015, as amended by the Cybercrimes (Prohibition, Prevention, etc.) (Amendment) Act, 2024.
Federal Republic of Nigeria. (2011). Evidence Act, 2011 (as amended). https://lawsofnigeria.placng.org/laws/EVIDENCE%20ACT.pdf?utm_source
Guttman, B., White, D. R., Williams, S., & Walraven, T. (2022). Digital evidence preservation: Considerations for evidence handlers (NISTIR 8387). National Institute of Standards and Technology.
United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. (n.d.). Handling of digital evidence. Education for Justice, Cybercrime Module 6.

Hans Offia is the founder and managing partner at Hans Offia & Associates, a top Nigerian law firm with offices strategically located in Abuja, Abakaliki and Lagos, Nigeria. He is in charge of the Firm’s Dispute resolution and Banking & Finance practice groups.